Skip to main content

I would really appreciate some constructive criticism on these mixes please! Thanks :)

I Can't Help Falling In Love With You (Guitar/Vocals)
Every Time We Say Goodbye (Piano/Vocals)

Dropbox folder:
https://www.dropbox.com/sh/bop28v4wdsj3lvh/AAAzPTarCDEOTT2PgbXVUpH4a?dl=0

Topic Tags

Comments

pcrecord Wed, 04/11/2018 - 16:22

Alright I got time to listen to your songs at my studio.
The ICHFILWY 1.mp3 sounds very thin and lowfi. Having like a cheap hyped condenser mic was used. Having just an instrument and panning it is a tricky choice.
I just feel not all the frequencies the guitar and voice has been captured properly.

ETWSG 1.mp3 (weird choice of file name)
Again the piano sound small , vocal a lot better. Thing is since the piano is centered, it fights for space with the vocal..
Recorded wider would make this breath more. in fact when I listen in mono, there isn't much of a difference in the sound (except for the reverb)

Could you explain the method of capture, it could help better understand what I'm hearing..
Nice voice tho.. please send more !

Outss Sun, 04/22/2018 - 12:04

Okay the piano sounds alright, although could maybe sound a bit bigger i hear some tinny high frequency bits come out now and then also, The vocal sound pretty clear, but feels like something is missing, maybe some sort of stereo placement it is lacking, my ears get bored. I actually prefer the guitar version, yeah it doesnt sound clean but the lofi aesthetic works nicely man. Maybe just bring some lows into the guitar or have a bass doing something minimal underneath. The vocals sound clear and present. Although when the hard strumming comes in, maybe could of made them wider then. Keep it up man, Its good they arent bad mixes. Just some tweaking. :)