1. Register NOW and become part of this fantastic knowledge base forum! This message will go away once you have registered.

Active/passive monitors

Discussion in 'Monitoring & Headphones' started by took-the-red-pill, Mar 12, 2005.

  1. took-the-red-pill

    took-the-red-pill Active Member

    Jan 10, 2005
    Near Clagary
    Home Page:
    Hi guys,

    Budget is a concern with me. Also I'd like to soffit mount my monitors if I can.

    Are there any very good reasons that you all know of to go with active, or passive monitors?

    Any recommendations as far as great bang for the buck?

  2. TeddyG

    TeddyG Well-Known Member

    Jan 20, 2005
    Wherever possible I buy "seperates". Everything! Seperate! Depending on what I'm buying, that can be pricey or at least more to figure out(More wires...). I think that one amp for every driver pair is best. Infinitely adjustable, repairable, replaceable, etc. So, my next speakers will likely be a nice, yet cheap, set of actives(I don't really care that much.).

    Truth, I swear! The actual "Sweatin' the tiny details/specs" speaker amp combo comes very close to being completely irrelevent. Not only will any good monitors work well in a good room, but, TRUTH TO TELL, most actual speaker difficiencies can be corrected by careful tuning of the room, along with rather simple "one time" speaker/amp EQ!!! Most room deficiences however CANNOT be solved by just EQ, filtering, etc., of ANY speakers/amp. Indeed, no matter how capable/expensive the speakers, the room itself ALWAYS needs to be matched to them. So if sweat need be sweated, sweat it on the room itself.

    Again, I'm only going so far with my room(Not very far), so it would be silly to go far with my speakers. I'll keep them small and close to me, hoping to minimize room effects(Good luck to me!). Wall-mounted speakers on the other hand really, no question, "use" the room as an integral part of the monitoring system!

    Get the speakers you want(The prettiest ones!) and mount them however you want, as long as your room is designed around them. May as well soffit mount them, as once they're "placed", in your proper room, no one will ever have to move them, or tweek anything on the back of them, to get a "better" sound - and they won't get bumped off the console!

    No kidding - the room size/design/quality itself will pretty well "short-list" which size/specs nice speakers, within your budget, will do the job(Most similarly priced/sized speakers sound, well... similar.) and only your time/research spent will tell you if you want to go with passive speakers(Which may be best, but..? Today, you may be talking genuine mili-fractions here.).

    A Google search for "soffit mounted speakers" brought-up lots of hits, including a nice, techy one(With graphs and everything!) from a big manufacturer - who should know speaker mounting - and speakers! From a quick read, it would seem that room size alone is an initial determinate as to whether to soffit mount or not? But, then again, that company sells ALOT of "console mounted" speakers? Maybe they're not "pushing" soffit mounting, today? Pays to get lots of opinions, hoping to glean a few facts... Good luck!

  3. JoeH

    JoeH Distinguished Member

    Jun 22, 2004
    Philadelphia, PA/ Greenville, DE
    Home Page:
    WELL SAID, Teddy G.

    Glad to see a voice of reason and sanity when it comes to speakers. ("Get the prettiest ones" made me chuckle, too!)

    Sometimes it comes down to that more than people will admit.... :cool:
  4. Kev

    Kev Well-Known Member

    Nov 13, 2001
    some speakers aren't suitable for soffit mounting

    having said that, I do love the soffit mounted style

    An excellent set of active monitors may in fact have the amps mounted seperate to the box containing the drivers

    the point I am making here is that when the budget is high and there is a no compromise attitude, then an active set of monitors should outperform seperates

    however this simply does not happen at the dollar level most of us are likely to be purchasing at

Share This Page