1. Register NOW and become part of this fantastic knowledge base forum! This message will go away once you have registered.

And the winner is...

Discussion in 'Recording' started by stickers, Dec 19, 2005.

  1. stickers

    stickers Active Member

    Lets have some fun..

    I'll post two clips of acoustic guitar. They will be 2 different takes with the same mic placement but different mics. You pick which mic/clip you like the SOUND of better. Our first contender will be called Mic A and our second contender will be Mic B. (Come on people..i don't want brand names to throw you off so the actual mics will remain anonymous for now.... )

    Diclaimer: I am not playing the guitar and he isnt very good but we are discussing sound quality so it really doesnt matter.

    The MP3s are 320 kbps so dont be pulling the "its an MP3 so I can't tell the difference line"

    MIC A [url]http://www.jetrecording.com/mica.mp3 [/URL]
    MIC B [url]http://www.jetrecording.com/micb.mp3 [/URL]

    Choose mic a or b and add why.
     
  2. Massive Mastering

    Massive Mastering Well-Known Member

    I'm not nuts about either of them (although I think it's the room), but the low end is well out of control in "A" and slightly more focused in "B."
     
  3. stickers

    stickers Active Member

    its a pretty dead space and the mic was no more than 6 inches away from the hole. Not sure how much "room sound" can be in there.
     
  4. stickers

    stickers Active Member

    So massive pick the lesser of 2 evils then, bucko.
     
  5. McCheese

    McCheese Well-Known Member

    Mic A sounded more natural to me, except for the excess in the low end.

    Mic B sounded better in the low end, but too midrangey to me.

    Between those two, I'd go with A and shelf the lows as a starting point.

    Cutting a tad of the mids on B might have some decent results though.
     
  6. Reggie

    Reggie Well-Known Member

    dang that's a toughy. They sound so different. I think A is more pleasant to listen to, but duller. B is way honky, but might stick out in a mix better. I fear no mids more than honky mids, so I'm gonna have to go with B. But it dang well better sound good on some other source if I was to choose it to buy.

    If I was going to guess, I would say that A was an SM81, and B was like a cheaper Audiotechnica, or a HM-1 or something
     
  7. Davedog

    Davedog Distinguished Member

    I'll play...

    Mic A....The lows are way out of proportion for the level of the track.

    Mic B...The mid-range is kinda standing around the fabled 500hz honk.


    The mic A will sound much better with the roll-off ingaged....if there is one.

    Mic B will sound better unplugged. Perhaps thats too much opinion....err...perhaps if it was EQ'd a touch. I liked the lowend on mic B but the lowmid honk seems better suited for an electric guitar.



    I will say that the guitar is partially the offending piece, perhaps more-so than either mic.

    Neither is an Audio Technica mic.....just a guess.
     
  8. stickers

    stickers Active Member

    The acoustic guitar is very nice. Pehhaps, the strings are too new if anything.
     
  9. Davedog

    Davedog Distinguished Member

    In that case lets move the mic up the neck a bit because I am hearing way too much soundhole.
     
  10. pr0gr4m

    pr0gr4m Well-Known Member

    I like the first one best. It sounds clearer.

    The second one sound.....pushy. The first 4 notes of it sounded like they came from a ukelele.

    I don't know if they are accurate, but the MP3 tag for mica shows SM-81 and HM-1 for micb. You may not want to put the mic name in the MP3 tags.
     
  11. imagineaudio

    imagineaudio Active Member

    i have a question. what's the point of this shoot out? given the right circumstances either of these mics could be used to record acoustic guitar. with this player, mic a moved further up the neck and possible cutting the lows would be a better choice. With a better guitar player in a nicer room mic b may be better, or maybe still mic a....


    ...seems like a pretty useless shootout to me, with no real point.
     

Share This Page