Full circle around a Blumlein Pair - a capella

Discussion in 'Location Recording' started by zemlin, Apr 25, 2006.

  1. zemlin

    zemlin Well-Known Member

    Had a fun recording on Sunday. A vocal group at a college about 90 minutes away hired me to record them for an archival CD for the members. 17 singers - I had them stand in a circle around a Blumlein pair (SPC3) with Oktava MK319s for lead vocal and beatbox. No beatbox on this piece, but ended up with some fun stereo placement quite by accident.

    http://www.cheap-tracks.com/mp3/cheap-tracks_kiss_sample2.mp3

    Preamp was a Sebatron VMP4000e into a MOTU 24i into Samplitude.
     
  2. MadMax

    MadMax Well-Known Member

    I sure hope you acoustic folks don't mind a nasty ol' multitracker in here too much...

    zemlin,

    I bet that WAS fun!

    When I get a gospel choir gig, I like to get the choir to do some stacking with a similar arrangement...

    I like to put em' in a circle around my SF12... either with the MP2MH or the DVC. (The VMP sound's great BTW!)

    Kind of a rough go sometimes... I've only got 10 pairs of headphones... The choir's got to bring some of their own, but I usually get it done w/o too much hastle. I just drag a 6 channel headphone distro and a BUNCH O' "Y"'s...

    It's fun just to watch em' walk around the mic talking... For fun, once I flipped L & R... one poor girl got so disoriented she had to sit down! :twisted:

    Max
     
  3. zemlin

    zemlin Well-Known Member

    No cans for this session. We were on the stage of a smallish auditorium - they were winging it for balance - soloists off the lead mic would step in to bring up their parts a bit - other than that they just checked their distance from the mics and balance by ear.

    There were two folks (besides me) monitoring on headphones and providing feeback to the singers.
     
  4. DavidSpearritt

    DavidSpearritt Well-Known Member

    I do hope you mean not all the way round in a circle, because you have to avoid putting anyone in the two out of phase quadrants.
     
  5. zemlin

    zemlin Well-Known Member

    Full circle. I'm completely aware that I had reversed left/right imaging on the back quadrants and reversed phase on the sides - that was the whole point of that setup - I wanted a big, wide sound. Mono compatibility is whacked with the voices on the sides - I know - but I seriously doubt this recording will ever see mono playback.

    Did you listen to the track? it sounds good to me.
     
  6. zemlin

    zemlin Well-Known Member

    A little more info and a fuzzy photo:
    The blumlein pair is a bit lost in the photo - but singers were in a full circle around the center pair. Lead vocal spot mic at 12:00. Beatbox spot mic at 6:00. Time aligned the lead and beat mics - had to flip phase on the beatbox mic, of course, since it's on the backside of the Blumlein mics.

    Earlham.jpg
    I guess there were only 16 singers. I didn't count them when I was there - I was told there'd be 17.
     
  7. jahtao

    jahtao Guest

    coool
     
  8. Cucco

    Cucco Distinguished Member

    For close-up "vocal in the round" this technique actually works just fine. In situations like this, think less "in-phase" and "out-of-phase" It's really not out of phase. The vocal aiming at the reverse lobe is actually in phase with themselves though yes, out of phase with the person directly on the other side - but that rarely matters in situations like this. Different parts are grouped similarly (SATB all grouped alike) and Soprano is across from Tenor, Alto across from Bass, there really isn't too much to worry about phase wise.

    Agreed, the result will sound a tad different than usual, but you'd be surprised just how well it can work. I've done this technique numerous times with a vocal group I record quite often. Usually, their shows are very diverse - they'll go from a full vocal with instrument ensemble down to a quartet and back to full chorus within any given concert. For these smaller quartet recordings, I typically do just that - blumlein with the singers positioned around it. Since you're primarily capturing direct sounds and little to no reflected sounds, there is little issue with phasing.

    J.
     
  9. zemlin

    zemlin Well-Known Member

    The singers on the sides (3:00 and 9:00) are singing into the front of one mic and the back of another, so when panned the cones are doing a push-me-pull-you thing that gives it that very wide sound - and it will cancel when played mono.

    It also sounds like total crap when played back with a "stereo enhancement" setup, like SRS or Q-Sound since those are playing with the phase.

    I think it sounds good when played through proper equipment though. I haven't tried it in my car yet.
     
  10. Cucco

    Cucco Distinguished Member

    I guess I didn't get your picture and description.

    When I've done this, I group individuals so that they are in fact facing a lobe. It sounds (and kind of looks - although, I don't see a blumlein array in your picture) as though you were doing a true circle...

    That can spell trouble as the point you've mentioned - when you're between lobes, you are in fact hitting opposite polarities. If it cancels in mono (which, in this case it should) that means it will also cancel when you are sitting in the sweet spot of the speakers.

    Have you thought about doing a double M/S on this one? (Not a TRUE double M/S more like a Mid/Side with a phase-flipped rear...)

    I haven't listened to your recording yet, but once I get to the studio, I will.

    J
     
  11. zemlin

    zemlin Well-Known Member

    I must confess, I had not thought through the total picture here until after the recording session - one of those "it seemed like a good idea at the time" moments. I'm still not sure I have any regrets, but I probably would do things differently if I were to do it again.

    I considered MS with or dual MS, but the Blumlein is what I chose.

    I'm not hearing cancellation (can you hear cancellation :-? ) with speakers - just a very wide image.
     
  12. hughesmr

    hughesmr Guest

    Karl,

    I'm curious ... which college did you record at?

    Mike
     
  13. zemlin

    zemlin Well-Known Member

    Earlham.
     
  14. hughesmr

    hughesmr Guest

    I ask because I recorded an all female a cappella group from Miami University in Ohio only a couple of weeks ago, and MU is roughly 90 minutes from Indy!

    I used a pr of Schoeps MK21 in NOS. In a live church, pickup was fairly close. I did the 'balance on the fly' too with soloists and beatbox.

    This wasn't by chance "The Cheezies," was it?

    Mike
     
  15. zemlin

    zemlin Well-Known Member

    No. I don't recall what they call themselves. It starts with a "B" - the Brimley's, perhaps?
     
  16. zemlin

    zemlin Well-Known Member

    DavidSpearritt,
    My reply to your post above was a bit defensive, but your message caused me to step back a bit and think more carefully about the phase relationships I had going on. As I said a few messages back, I'm not sure I regret what I did, but I see how I could have done things differently and how my approach may have some problematic side effects (no pun intended). My thoughts about what I was getting were incorrect the day of the recording. Thanks for the wakeup call.

    ... always learning ...
     
  17. David French

    David French Well-Known Member

    Definitely wrong in theory, but I definitely don't care. Sounds fine to me.

    One gripe - I prefer hiss to denoising artifacts anyday.

    All in all, I'm sure they were thrilled as can be with this recording.
     
  18. DavidSpearritt

    DavidSpearritt Well-Known Member

    No offence taken. I listened after typing my post, but knew for sure you had problems with the "all round the blumlein array" approach. The 9 and 3 o'clock quadrants are strictly out of bounds for the blumlein pickup, but not for singing into spot mics.

    This recording is OK, a lot better than I thought, but I can hear some phase weirdness as well.

    We recorded the Ten Tenors in a front/back around two KM120's in Blumlein, and had two spot mics, 1 vocal and 1 for piano, further back in the out of phase quadrants. It worked well because the two groups of 5 singers standing opposite each other were phase coherant, although reversed. The accenting of spots in the out of phase quadrants needed to be up higher than normal, to cancel the incorrect phase cues from the KM120's.

    Overall, we got a fantastic blend and balance with minimal channels, this is motivation enough to try this complex technique. But there are lots of traps. I also had to put two long crosshairs in Gaffa on the studio floor, to keep the wild, joking, tenors shenanagans in the bounds of the array, and demanded bare feet, particularly when the soloists had to step round into the out of phase quadrants to sing into the M149.

    My inspiration for this technique came from an article in Audio Technology magazine when Simmo interviewed Bob Katz re I Ching recording for Chesky.
     
  19. Cucco

    Cucco Distinguished Member

    Amen!!!

    I still haven't listened to the recording yet...sorry. But, I agree with David 110% The human ear has an amazing noise reduction system. When presented with music and common/natural noise such as hiss or rumble, we can easily filter that out and act as though it doesn't even exist. However, artifacts are very un-natural and thus call attention to themselves.

    My take on noise is always - "Embrace the noise." Getting rid of it only causes far worse problems. There are ways to minimize it. For example, I just did a recording in this local hall where the lighting system is cooled by this incredibly loud system which is located just in the right wing of the stage. The orchestra did Williams' Fantasia on Greensleeves where harp and flute have a long portion of the piece by themselves. I was able to filter much of the offensive noise out by a simple high-pass filter at ~100Hz and gently crossfade in and out of this steep filter when appropriate. Sure there's still noise there, but it's easily ignored.

    Just some thoughts...
    J.
     
  20. zemlin

    zemlin Well-Known Member

    NR on this was to kill rumbling A/C noise. I actually thought it had come through pretty clean. :oops: I'll need to turn up the volume a bit and listen again. I'll blame some of it on MP3 compression ... yeah, that's it.

    I can't tell here at work - my cans are very open and the A/C here is very noisy.
     

Share This Page