1. Register NOW and become part of this fantastic knowledge base forum! This message will go away once you have registered.

mix with flat monitors or with colored "hifi" moni

Discussion in 'Monitoring / Headphones' started by camsr, Jul 28, 2007.

  1. camsr

    camsr Active Member

    Which monitors will help to translate a mix better? Alot of music is listened to on a hifi system (here hifi meaning a system that mimics an equal loudness contour), so I am assuming if you mix on a hifi, then the actual recording comes out 'flat' in a way. But if you mix on a system with a flat response, and you try to to give it an equal loudness contour, when that mix is played back on a hifi, it will mimic the loudness contour twice.

    So my question is which really better for mixing, flat monitors or "hifi" monitors? Does it depend alot on where the music is played? (movie theater, club, ipod, home stereo)
     
  2. MadMax

    MadMax Well-Known Member

    A lot of music may be listened to on hifi speakers... but it's generally hard to MIX on em and get a good mix.

    Let's say the speakers have a boost at 200, 400, 2kHz and 4KHz. When you try to mix on these, you will hear exaggerated 200, 400, 2kHHz and 4kHz.

    Because the boost is there, you can about bet that your mixes will be too thin at those frequencies, because you are gonna cut those frequencies... cause they're too loud.

    Make sense?
     
  3. natural

    natural Active Member

    I agree with madmax.
    It would only work to mix on 'Hi Fi' speakers if ALL hifi speakers were the same.
    Since it's not a perfect world, you need to mix on a Flat system, so that all the different hifi speakers can mangle your audio in their own special way.

    There used to be a saying "if you can make it sound good on a crappy pair of speakers it will sound good anywhere.
    This couldn't be further from the truth. It will only sound good that that particular pair of crappy speakers and will sound extra crappy everywhere else.
     
  4. UncleBob58

    UncleBob58 Active Member

    Flat monitors.

    Tuned room.
     
  5. pr0gr4m

    pr0gr4m Well-Known Member

    I tuned by room to B flat!
     
  6. TheFraz

    TheFraz Active Member

    mix on flat monitors then reference it on your hifi system.
    it will be a good test to see how it translates.
     
  7. dementedchord

    dementedchord Well-Known Member

    i'm all for flat... i just dont get why most people assume that hi-fi isn't... granted there's alot of seriously shitty hi-fi out there... but if you've got anything approaching audiophile quality stuff you should have no problem... the problem isn't hi-fi... it's LOW/NO -fi...
     
  8. MadMax

    MadMax Well-Known Member

    Agreed dementedchord...

    To me the difference is in what people call hi fi, "hi fi" and audiophile.

    I wouldn't say you could expect Polk Audio to be dependable to give you a great mix. Proac's... probably.

    Kinda' like the statement... "I can't TELL you what's pornographic... but I KNOW it when I see it."
     
  9. Link555

    Link555 Well-Known Member

    I think You need both. My monitor set up consists of three sets of speakers.
    1) My main monitors (Dynaudio BM15A)
    2) horrible tones 1 (Hitachi book shelve speakers)
    3) really horrible tones 2 (Sony Geto-blaster speakers)

    I use a cranesong avocet to switch through the monitors. Once I get a mix close, on 1 I check it on 2 and 3, and tweak a bit more. This way I try to find a balance.

    I also then use the car speakers, and our other book shelve stereo speakers to double check with different acoustics and set ups.
     
  10. camsr

    camsr Active Member

    I've come to the conclusion flat is best. I did kinda misuse the term hi-fi. All quality systems should be as flat as they can, and mixing monitors the same. So that way what goes in, should come out. Chalk it up to many years of me mixing on shitty loudspeakers. Thanks.
     
  11. TheBear

    TheBear Guest

    like a few have said, use both try and get a mix that suits both speakers. cuz not everyone that hears the music u mix has awesome speakers. so you gotta mix for them and for those that do have hi-fi.
     

Share This Page