1. Register NOW and become part of this fantastic knowledge base forum! This message will go away once you have registered.

Monitoring upgrades: ditch which?

Discussion in 'Recording' started by godotzilla, Sep 9, 2003.

  1. godotzilla

    godotzilla Guest

    I'm looking at making some upgrades to my monitoring system to the tune of around $500. I currently use a pair of Tannoy Proto Js and an Alesis RA-100. Am I better off getting new speakers or a better amp? Are the Tannoy Reveal (passives) going to be a significant improvement over the Protos?

    Or should I just ditch the whole thing and get a set of powered MSP5?
     
  2. AudioGaff

    AudioGaff Well-Known Member

    Depending on the room you use to listen and mix in, you might very well be better served in spending that money on acoustic room treatment so that your not hearing and fighting problems that new monitors will never fix.
     
  3. error5i

    error5i Guest

    I was wondering about the Tannoy Proto J's myself im thinking about getting them and I actually have the same Amp as you, right now i have the Maudio BX5 so i am pretty sure it will be a nice upgrade, just wondering what you didnt like about the tannoys??
     
  4. Davedog

    Davedog Distinguished Member

    Da 'Gaff makes a very IMPORTANT point here.Most of the time.....MOST!....its not so much the speakers or the amp but the listening environment.Its unfortunate that there is so much marketing hype out there that folks think they're only a purchase away from sonic nirvana.Even a modest set of monitors will sound very good and operate at a high enough level that you'll be able to achieve a decent view of a mix in a good sounding room.Placement in the room is important.Objects surrounding your monitors' make a great deal of difference.Your listening position is a factor that is grossly overlooked in a lot of cases.There are rules for these things.Physics is a real science and should be attended to with as much of a budget as the gear itself.Yet this is one of the things left to a 'maybe' on most lists.Do your research...there are many threads on here and many others groups dealing with this very thing.Move your monitors around some...change your listening position.Chances are you will save a great deal of money in the short run, and in the long run you will actually learn some truths to this engineering business that you will use as long as you're at it.

    If you are deadset on spending some money, for under $20 you can purchase a db meter from Radio Shaq that will help you determine just how loud you're mixing and listening.It will REALLY help. At 85db, most monitors can faithfully reproduce all of the frequencies found in a basic mix.If ,of course, they're situated properly.
     

Share This Page