1. Register NOW and become part of this fantastic knowledge base forum! This message will go away once you have registered.

Sound replacment on major rock records?

Discussion in 'Recording' started by planet red, Apr 11, 2002.

  1. planet red

    planet red Active Member

    Jul 25, 2001
    So are most of the drummers for these bands EXTREMELY accurate and consistant or is it common practice to add kick and snare samples? ( i know terry date does) Where do you normally find good samples and how do use them? Generally when you use a sample do you not rely on the original at all or do you pick something that will compliment what you have and lay it under the original. When I use samples I normally have a hard time getting them to fit, and either give up, or turn the original way down. So whats the scoop? Anyone know of any good drum sample cd's for when the drummer brings in shitty equipment and doesnt know how to play?
  2. drundall

    drundall Guest

    Common practice.
    Many people take samples at the start of the session for later use in mixing.

    If you're having a heard time getting samples to blend in, check to see that they're in time with the original (they're usually a little late, so you have to nudge them back to line them up).

    I go for the blend rather than total replacement.

    Hope this helps.
  3. Nimrod

    Nimrod Guest

    Great sample CDs for drums

    Pure Drums by Yellow tools
    Bob Clearmountain Drums

    Think about Battery PT studio edition which is a Native instruments RTAS plug which is a great sampler with low latency and they have some great sample banks and I think Yellow tools has done some 24 bit samples for them as well. This is a convenient way to get time accurate samples into your mix. i know what you mean about sloppy drummers, I recently dropped the drums from a track and just used some loops by Conti, you know what the song rocked. I think its poor drummers that sometimes gets PT a bad name. jules said once that to get a great drum sound in PT you need one over the age of 35 who can really play + Apogee + Fatso and alll that stuff :D
  4. planet red

    planet red Active Member

    Jul 25, 2001
    Making sure they're on time is a bitch. Soundreplacer always wants to drop every 10th hit or so a couple miliseconds in front of the original. I normally spend like 5 to 10 minutes going thru and making sure they're all on time. Maybe I'll try to make a couple of my own samples before I start mixing the thing im working on now.

    Where would one pick up the clearmountain disk? Does it have a lot of different sounding snares and kicks? Is it pricy? Some of those sample cd's seem ridiculously overpriced.
  5. RecorderMan

    RecorderMan Distinguished Member

    Mar 28, 2001
    I raelly hate to use samples,,,although it is an nescessary evil sometimes. Blending is usually better. If the snare doesn't have enough, "snares", "shell" "crack", ect. Pick a sample to blend with that does. Andy Wallace used to use a snare hit reverb sample that he's add. Dave Jerden, Back when the Forat was the rage would use 2 kick and 4 snare samples that he would blend accordingly.
    If you have access to Pro Tools, sound replacer is the greatest little thing ever for this purpose.

    a GREAT sample cd is The RossGarfield Drum Docters CD. I like it better than Clearmountains, because Ross used his extensive DrumRental collection; so there is just about every kind of snare,kick & tom sound (along w/cymbs & hats.etc) needed to reinforce what you're lacking.

    If anybody needs the fullproof/ in sync analog set up for triggering I'd be happy to type it out.
  6. RandomGuest

    RandomGuest Guest

    Feb 10, 2001
    Do you guys all know that SoundReplacer (TDM ProTools plug in) operates in stereo? That you can use stereo samples with it?

    It took me a year and a half to figure that out! :eek:

  7. erockerboy

    erockerboy Guest

    Rather than mess around with finding a sampled snare or kick that blends well with the live kit sound, my fave option is to take samples of the actual drumkit at the beginning of the session while the drummer is fresh, and then use those as needed. (Of course if the kit sucks that's probably not such a great idea. :( )

    Make sure to grab a few variations of each drum hit, so all the consecutive hits don't have to be identical... big pet peeve of mine!

    Apart from that, here are some "sleeper" sample CD's not mentioned above. I personally really like the Sweetwater Total Session Drums for Kurzweil. Also "Rhythm Section Volume 1" from the old Roland S-series sample library is surprisingly usable. "Drum & Percussion Tools" from Time and Space is good, and cheap too ($39 at SoundsOnline I think?). You can use the Translator software from Chickensys to convert those samples into your desired target format.

    Good luck!
  8. e-cue

    e-cue Active Member

    Oct 5, 2000
    As much as a fan as I am of what Bob Clearmountain has accomplished, his sample cd's are kinda weak in my opinion. As a matter a fact, I have yet to be impressed with any sound cd (especially at @$100 a pop). At the end of every mix I do, I have a "drum dat" that I have my assistant lay all the drums down. I know a couple other engineers that do this, and we swap from time to time. I also lift samples from CD's on the market. If I hear an open snare, I grab it. I've been doing this for years with my F-16. Over time you'll have an arsonal of samples (I'm at about 5 gigs which is a lot considering how small each sample is)... I love pitch shifting my kicks to the key of the song.
    Also, sometimes the sample you need sounds like crap by itself. You might, for example, have the greatest low end on a kick drum, but no definition, so you add a "click" sample to it (like the beater sound you get on a death metal kick drum). By the way jules, I'd love to see this site get a "sample trading" section... I'd visit hourly.
  9. RandomGuest

    RandomGuest Guest

    Feb 10, 2001
    "I'd love to see this site get a "sample trading" section... I'd visit hourly. "

    Thats a good idea!

    Also the end of mix idea... Thing is, getting samples that work in a mix without TOO much processing... that makes sence to run em off while a mix is still up... DOH!

  10. zeuss

    zeuss Guest

    Seeying that some of you use samples with the actual track what do you do to get rid of that slight phasing of say a kick track with a kick sample? Especially when you use the same sound. Even when using sound replacer the sampled sound is still like 5 to 10 samples off and varies for every hit. I understand that you would not want the sampled sound above the real track but slightly behind but with kicks I can still hear it in the high end especially if its a slappy type of kick sound. I usually roll a little high end off of one of them. Or "GO IN" and move every hit so they are in perfect sync. Has anyone here come across that situation? And what do you do about it?

  11. planet red

    planet red Active Member

    Jul 25, 2001
    Yeah soundreplacer can be a bitch when it wont put the sample right on time with sound. I always end up manually sliding them around. It really sucks to waste a bunch of time doing this though, so i dont bother using it unless the drums REALLY need it. If it worked perfectly i'd probably always drop a sample in way in the background to add a little something to kick and snare. But since it ends up taking so much time, i only do it if it really needs to be done, and will be loud in the mix.
  12. RecorderMan

    RecorderMan Distinguished Member

    Mar 28, 2001
    Doh...I've heard/read that before. But my own ingenuitty coupled with my apathy and laziness has led me to futillity in using stereo samples.
    Please tell how you do....
  13. sturgis58

    sturgis58 Guest

    No one is using/trying Discrete Drums yet? I bought the full 12 disc set about a month ago, still in the process of going thru them. 12 CD's is a massive amount of material to go thru. Besides all of the loop material, there's a very decent sample disc...
  14. Johnjm22

    Johnjm22 Guest

    I usally always replace my kick and snare tracks with samples, but I find this very difficult with toms. It just seems like when ever you replace the tom tracks they sound very stiff and fake, and they never want to sit in the mix.

    Anyone else have this problem and have any ideas on how to fix it?
  15. boheme6

    boheme6 Guest

    for good samples check out Sonic Reality's 'Interactive Drums'.. really good stuff.

    There's a new one out called DFH (Drumkit from Hell) Superior that's 35G.. not Megs.. GIGS. of drum samples..

    holy disk space, batman.
  16. Johnjm22

    Johnjm22 Guest

    Are all these "Good" sample CD's you guys are talking about in 24bit 96K?

    I bought a sample cd off ebay for like 10 bucks, and there was some decent samples on it, but it bothered me not know what it was recorded in.
  17. doulos21

    doulos21 Guest

    i second drum kit from hell as well as discrete drums both very good sample solutions

Share This Page