1. Register NOW and become part of this fantastic knowledge base forum! This message will go away once you have registered.

X/Y or Stero/Mono, by recording drums

Discussion in 'Drums' started by Cezarius, Nov 14, 2007.

  1. Cezarius

    Cezarius Guest

    Hi. I would like to ask, what position of overheads is better by drum recording. I use X/Y type of overhead position, but in some recording seminars, thah lern to record drum kit as well, explain Stereo/Mono mode and 3 in 1 rule. I now that there are more another types, byt i want to lern about this (X/Y or Stero/Mono). Please explain which type is better.
    Thanks :wink:
  2. Boswell

    Boswell Distinguished Moderator Resource Member

    Apr 19, 2006
    Home Page:
    Goto Youtube and search on "drum recording". You get over 6000 hits. Of the top few, the Presonus offering is reasonably comprehensive, if a little idiosyncratic. Try also "Recorderman".

    TWYLALTR (take what you like and leave the rest).
  3. Davedog

    Davedog Distinguished Member

    Dec 10, 2001
    Pacific NW
    The choice of technique in placing mics as overheads for a drum kit is entirely subjective and really has no answer to your question of 'best'.....

    The room, the kit, the style of music, the drummers technique....all have as much to do with the choice of pattern as well as the choice of mic, mic positioning,preamp selection, and even the orientation of the drums in the room they're being recorded in.

    The 'best' choice is whats best for that moment.
  4. RemyRAD

    RemyRAD Guest

    Sep 26, 2005
    XY can be nice for straightahead jazz. But most of us end up utilizing 2 microphone stands with booms on either side of the drum set. It helps to provide a greater sense of stereo-phonic separation, than the predominantly mono like quality from XY. Conversely, ORTF will provide a slightly better stereo image as will MS/middle side. But let's be practical, it's much easier to use 2 separate microphone stands and booms for two separate microphone overheads.

    Doesn't anybody ever watch television anymore? Most variety shows demonstrate a how to vision to microphone up drums. These television shows have not employed beginner amateurs to put microphones on drums. They are highly skilled and highly paid professionals like myself. It makes me think that everybody is blind here? It just makes you wonder how people read these posts? Obviously, many people can't or don't read these posts as these questions regularly appear. I think most are blinded by stupid things they read by people who don't do what they write about.

    Nobody here has written about the phase problems of having 4 newscaster's virtually sitting shoulder to shoulder. In that respect, it doesn't matter if you are using directional for omnidirectional microphones. That's where you cannot follow the 3 to 1 recommendation of microphone placement separation. That's what mixing is all about. You have to quickly ride levels which means some pretty fast finger moves and not upon your girlfriends. Electronic devices and other blah blah doesn't cut it.

    So I recommend popping open a couple of beers and watching some serious variety late-night programming.

    Jay Leno, David Letterman and Saturday Night Live come to mind. I too have engineered late night TV variety shows. You will get so proficient at moving your fingers quickly, you may find an improvement in your masturbation technique? One can only hope.

    Fast fingered girl
    Ms. Remy Ann David
  5. Cucco

    Cucco Distinguished Member

    Mar 8, 2004
    Fredericksburg, VA
    Remy...you're dating yourself. Variety shows haven't been on TV since Rowen and Martin and perhaps the Bradys.

    Although, there was the muppets. That Animal was a bitchin drummer!
  6. RemyRAD

    RemyRAD Guest

    Sep 26, 2005
    Actually, I think I worked on the last variety show here in Washington DC? It was for our entertainment critic Arch Campbell at the NBC owned and operated W. R. C. Channel 4. It was a real variety show and a lot of fun at that. And of course during ratings, the funniest show was all of these local drag queens! The funniest one was this guy who did Cindy Lauper's " Girls Just Want To Have Fun". Actual Real Hysterical Entertainment. I Miss That Show. I engineered everything on the Neve I now own. We Would Have Real Bands in That I Got to Mike up and Fly by the Seat of My Pants mixing since there was no multitrack nor postproduction performed. Our Mini Tonight Show. I Would Love to do Live Game Shows and/or other Variety Shows. That's why I should look into LA or Orlando? It's too cold in NYC.

    The good old days
    Ms. Remy Ann David
  7. freaky

    freaky Guest

    It seems variety shows aren't the only way Remy's dating herself!!! :shock:

    Sorry, I just couldn't resist that one :twisted:
  8. RemyRAD

    RemyRAD Guest

    Sep 26, 2005
    freaky? Do say. You've got to get it when you can.

    Although I can admit I have enjoyed making binaural recordings and other things bi.....like microphones. I guess it's probably also safe to say that I too am the woman of my dreams. Which I guess could sound slightly schizophrenic if it wasn't for the fact that I'm both a broadcaster and recording engineer.

    Adapter Raptor Rapture
    Ms. Remy Ann David

    Or should that be the other way around? Not be? Be not as it may.....

Share This Page