Nate: Yam P80 vs. Roland FP3

S

Strad

Guest
So---
I have boiled my choice down to these two 88 weighted keys in my price range.....what do you think ??

toss-up??
 

Nate Tschetter

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2001
Hi Strad

It comes down to action and sounds. Can you put up with the Roland action? I can't. But I must temper that again by saying I've been playing Yamaha's weighted and unweighted action for years. I cannot stand any other manufacturer's weighted action.

And, I'm pretty much the same with the sounds. I haven't played the current FP, but i played one of the first ones. I thought it was a good idea but I couldn't get with that "RD-ish" sound. Cool for Rock but I'm a Jazz guy. Although the P80 ain't perfect, the sound is nice and playable.

However, this is a preference. See if you can borrow or buy (with the intent to return one - rare in the MI market) both for a week and see which one works best.

As always, YMMV

PS - "YMMV" always makes me think of "YMCA"
 
Top