Skip to main content
Connecting the recording world together...

When I was a kid, I used to record the radio on to a cassette tape. How to I record internet audio in my DAW? Is there and internet i/o in logic?

Comments

Boswell Mon, 04/26/2010 - 04:58

You should not have any internet I/O enabled on your DAW for latency and dropout reasons. Keep a separate clunky old PC running Windows98 available with internet connection for the streaming audio job. W98 had a "Wave Out Mix" source option for digitally recording streaming output back into your audio application. This was removed in NT-class operating systems (NT2000, XP, Vista, W7 etc). A simple application such as "Sound Recorder" is OK for capturing the files, and then you can transfer them to your DAW system by USB memory stick.

Boswell Fri, 04/30/2010 - 02:57

The bit about not having your DAW connected to the web applies both to PCs and Macs. Although all versions of Windows are particularly bad at starving audio I/O of processor time during network activity, MAC OSX is not a whole lot better, and neither type of system is immune to drop-outs if networking is enabled and active.

That said, an app like Soundflower sounds like a good thing to try for the purpose of routing streaming audio back into another app.

thatjeffguy Fri, 04/30/2010 - 09:53

Boswell, couldn't disagree more... maybe "in theory" you are correct, but in 10 years operating a commercial studio on Macs, I have always been connected to the internet and have never experienced ANY related problems. In addition, I usually have 4 to 6 other apps open while tracking or editing in Cubase... NO problems. I'm sorry if your experience has been different, but please refrain from painting generalities that do not bear out in experience.

Jeff

Boswell Fri, 04/30/2010 - 10:23

Jeff - I'm glad your experience has been a good one. However, too many of the audio dropout problems we have to deal with on this forum have been due to having TCP/IP stacks running while audio I/O is in progress. The general RO forum advice, which I stand by, is not to mix networking and multi-channel audio I/O, but there will be specific cases where you can get away with it.

thatjeffguy Fri, 04/30/2010 - 10:41

Boswell, thanks for the response.

In my experience, people who experience audio dropouts are trying to push their hardware too much because they have not kept their equipment up to date. So perhaps yes, if you're running out-of-date, underpowered equipment and trying to push it beyond its limit, you'll have problems.

But I still hold that to paint your position as a universal truth of audio recording technology is simply misleading, my experience as example. There is no problem having your computer connected to the internet (and I can only speak for the Mac side of computing) while doing audio recording and/or mixing provided you operate a computer that is adequately powered (processors, RAM, hard drives) for the tasks at hand.

As computer hardware becomes more capable, both operating systems and applications are written with the newest in mind. This requires that one keep updated hardware to keep things operating smoothly. To do otherwise is asking for trouble and leads to the type of work-around blanket statements that you make here, which should be better relegated, perhaps, to troubleshooting tips, e.g. "If you are experiencing audio dropouts, try disabling your internet connection and see if that helps" rather than accepted "rules of the road".

Jeff