Control 24 or Sony DmxR100

Discussion in 'Mixing & Song Critique' started by JDirty, Aug 12, 2004.


Sony DMXR100 or Digidesign Contr0l 24

  1. Sony

  2. Digidesign

    0 vote(s)
  1. JDirty

    JDirty Guest

    I have a chance to get a great deal on one of these, but I am kind of torn. I mean yeah the sony would be more compatible with other formats instead of the tdm control 24, but this is for an expansion to the studio, which already is using DP3, so we are trying to get a pro tools rig. So I am at a crossroads. So many people are telling me the Sony, the Sony the Sony.. but the fact of the matter is, we are only going to be using this rig for pro tools anyways, so why wouldnt I get the control 24?? Its cheaper first of all. I dont know. You guys tell me what you think... :? Thanks ..
  2. Blueberry

    Blueberry Active Member

    Aug 6, 2003
    New York
    Home Page:
    The Sony is a great board, the mic pre's sound better than the Focusrite Platinum serires in the Control 24. Not to mention it has the nice Oxford EQ and dynamics that everyone loves. It really feel like a pro mixer.

    However I would check to see how well it works as a controller in PT. If you can control faders, solo, mute, transport controls, then it becomes a little more apealing.

    With PT of course the main appeal is the plug ins. You can get almost any plugin for PT however each plugin will cost you over a grand. It is kinda nice to have the Sony plugins in your board. This means not opening up more screens and playing with a mouse.
    You will find with every controller, that it is just easier to do certain functions outside the main controls as mentioned above with a mouse.

    With that said, the Control 24 makes working with Pro Tools one of the most easiest work flows you could ask for. Plus you have the scribble strips in front of you for each channel. The latest update software for the Sony added it on the main screen, but it is not as nice. With all this being said, though I like the Sony, I would get the PT. You can even get the Oxford plug ins for the PT which now includes the George Massenburg EQ. However read this. SOS article
  3. JDirty

    JDirty Guest

    Thanks for the info.. I am really all for the sony and like I said everyone keeps telling me the sony is the better board, but for the price difference, I could get a neve mic pre, and still afford more plugins. Dont get me wrong The sonys pre do sound great, but I am in love the Neve's.
    And I agree, that with a pro tools rig a control 24 as a front end will fit in better in the grand scheme of things.. Thanks again.
  4. djui5

    djui5 Guest

    I love the sony.....much more than the control 24...
  5. sheet

    sheet Well-Known Member

    May 28, 2003
    Kansas City, KS
    Home Page:
    You cannot compare the two because one is a console (soon to receive no Sony support), and one "emulates" a console, and seemlessly integrates with PT. The Sony does not seemlessly integrate with PT. In fact, I do not believe that it has HUI compatibility. HUI doesn't give you total control, just basic fader and transport, etc
  6. Duardo

    Duardo Guest

    That's right, it's an apples-to-oranges comparison. If you're looking at it primarily for use with Pro Tools, I'd say go with the Control's cheaper, and likely to be more "future proof". In a way, the DMXR100 is already maxes out at 96k (not that recording at 192 is a necessity, but that's another topic altogether) so if you have clients who want to work at 192kHz they wouldn't be able to with the DMX. The Control 24 doesn't care, so if Digidesign decided next week to move to a 32-bit or DSD format (or something else entirely) the Control 24 would be compatible right off the bat.

    And with the money you save, you can buy the preamps you really that would smoke the preamps in either board.

  • AT5047

    The New AT5047 Premier Studio Microphone Purity Transformed

Share This Page