Logic x.x vs. DP 3 vs. PT 5.1 LE

Discussion in 'Mixing & Song Critique' started by jeronimo, Jan 31, 2002.

  1. jeronimo

    jeronimo Guest

    I'm using PT LE right now and I have a very stable system. The only reason I have to forget PT and go for DP or Logic is horsepower to mix... DP is dual processor ready and logic is altivec ready... ohhh, I forgot about the track count on PT LE :) .
    But I do love the stability and editing on PT. So far, I couldn't find out how to do some serious editing on DP 3 or logic... I mean... serious, FAST editing.
    I use those for AUDIO only, almost no MIDI at all.
    Can you guys comment/suggest my post?
  2. Dedric

    Dedric Guest

    Personally, I don't think Logic is as elegant for editing audio as some other systems (I use Paris for audio, and Logic for midi), but it can be powerful once you learn it, and certainly is about the most powerful for midi.

    If you are going audio only, there are probably easier solutions than Logic. Another option is Nuendo. Some say the editing is easier than PT and more full-featured - multi-level undo seems like a REALLY big plus. It is also multiprocessor ready, IIRC. The users I've talked to say Nuendo sounds very very good, but I don't have experience with it to compare to PT LE, Logic or DP.

  3. jeronimo

    jeronimo Guest

    Thanks for your reply Dedric. I totally agree with what you said. Let's say I have 100 hours of experience w/ PT, I should have 15 hours w/ Logic and 30 w/ DP 3. I found Logic very complicated and both Logic and DP miss some small details that PT has and makes your life much, much easier. Is there a Nuendo version out already? Thanks again!
  4. cdp

    cdp Active Member

    Mar 13, 2001
    Home Page:
    What features did Logic lack for you?

    I have not used paris or nuendo, but I've been through a whole mess of others, like pt and dp... Logic can be less intuitive at first, but once you find your way of working with it, I can't think of any programs with more "balance."

    As far as speed goes, that's really all about how accustomed you are to the program. I find Logic to be very very fast...

    Take care,

    Charles Di Pinto
  5. jeronimo

    jeronimo Guest

    Hey Charles, I think I need to see some 'real' pro engineer working with Logic to 'measure' how fast he edits... I can say I edit pretty damn fast with PT... but... how can I measure.
  • AT5047

    The New AT5047 Premier Studio Microphone Purity Transformed

Share This Page

  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice