Skip to main content

Hi all,

i want your opinion about the best sounding ad da converters on the market these days ?

i'm a recording mastering engineer and i'm using outboard gear (tube eq's and compression) when i master and i'm using the RME ad's and they are good converters,i am satisfied with their results in recordings, but in mastering they are ok,i'm sure there are better ones

Comments

Michael Fossenkemper Sat, 11/06/2004 - 17:09

Weiss would be one of my first choices. Lavry gold or blue are excellent. Mytek, Apogee rosetta 200, Prism, Benchmark, DCS, Even the Waves L2 converters sound good. I found that I like a little flavor so I like to have a few to choose from. For the Money, I really like the Apogee Rosetta 200. I think they sound very good, have some great usefull features. If money were no object, then I would look at the Weiss and Lavry.

TanTan Sun, 11/14/2004 - 15:53

well , i've done my research and stil don't have a clue , i will defenetly go for bencmark weiss lavry .
the strange thing about it , is there's a huge price differences betwin them , and they all under the same category, i couldn't really realize the difference betwin lavry gold blue did someone ever ab'd the benchmarkweisslavry ? or the lavry goldblue?

THANK YOU !

Michael Fossenkemper Sun, 11/14/2004 - 16:38

well the gold is his better converter. The blue still sounds great but it's expensive to get that extra 10%. Weiss is really good. Benchmark is a great deal for the money. The blue line, you can configure to taste. If you want 2 a/d's and and SRC and a d/a, you can do that. Basically it's set up in modules and you can load to taste. You have to look at the features in each converter. The benchmark is just a d/a, so that's why it's much cheaper. What are you looking to use it for?

anonymous Mon, 11/15/2004 - 05:31

Thomas W. Bethel wrote: We use AES/EBU interfaces for all our digital connections. We are using an RME digital audio card which supports this format in our DAW and a AES/EBU router from ZSystems which also supports this format to do all our patching.

Hope this helps.

Thanx. :)

Seems like my RME card also support AES/EBU. :)

Cheers
Bob
:roll:

Massive Mastering Mon, 11/15/2004 - 09:41

An alternate to the Z-Sys unit would be the Lynx AES router. It's incredibly flexible, but it's PC based. Not an issue to some, but somethign to keep in mind.

And Bob, there are converters that go between AES/EBU and S/PDIF out there if you can find them. They're relatively inexpensive. I try to stay AES wherever possible, but if you've got some gear that you like with S/PDIF, you don't have to get rid of it or anything...

TanTan Mon, 11/15/2004 - 14:07

Michael Fossenkemper wrote: well the gold is his better converter. The blue still sounds great but it's expensive to get that extra 10%. Weiss is really good. Benchmark is a great deal for the money. The blue line, you can configure to taste. If you want 2 a/d's and and SRC and a d/a, you can do that. Basically it's set up in modules and you can load to taste. You have to look at the features in each converter. The benchmark is just a d/a, so that's why it's much cheaper. What are you looking to use it for?

Thank you Michael , i have several uses for it . i'm tracking mixing and mastering in my studio, so , for tracking obviously i need high end converters, if it's a multitrack recording session so i won't mind using my rme for recording drums , but when it come to vocal recordings it's very important (and it's ok for me not having tons of high end ad's because for the projects i'm working on it's mainly one instrument at a time) i'm mastering through some analog gear so in this point the ada is very important to me, maybe i'll need more da's because i'm soon to finish my custom made mixing desk and then i'll sum it all analog and converters will be the most important thing .

anonymous Sun, 12/05/2004 - 10:36

What about the Lynx converters. I've heard from many people that the Lynx2 sounds just as good, if not better than the Apogee stuff. Don't know if has been compared to the new Rosetta's though.

Lynx also has the new Aurora's coming out, which they advertise as "Mastering Quality" converters. If they truly are THAT good, I plan on picking up the Aurora 16. Sixteen channels of "Mastering Quality" conversion for something like $3500 is a damn good deal.

Ammitsboel Sun, 12/05/2004 - 11:42

Johnjm22 wrote: What about the Lynx converters. I've heard from many people that the Lynx2 sounds just as good, if not better than the Apogee stuff. Don't know if has been compared to the new Rosetta's though.

Lynx also has the new Aurora's coming out, which they advertise as "Mastering Quality" converters. If they truly are THAT good, I plan on picking up the Aurora 16. Sixteen channels of "Mastering Quality" conversion for something like $3500 is a damn good deal.

As in every other thing in life, you will never know untill you have tried it.

I have the AES16 card witch is a good AES/EBU audio routing card but my DA converter needed a very high quality AES/EBU signal and with the standart Lynx cable and the standart parts on the PCI card my converter revealed some low quality transfering parts and low quality cable. So I modified the AES16 card to sound better and much more contrasted through my converter, I would say that i got an improvement of over 50%.

So lynx is good, but to call it mastering quality...? Well maybe it is when considering all the compromises that is legalized in mastering. So what I'm saying is that Lynx isn't High End.

Best Regards

timster Mon, 12/06/2004 - 21:08

Ammitsboel wrote: [quote=Johnjm22]What about the Lynx converters. I've heard from many people that the Lynx2 sounds just as good, if not better than the Apogee stuff. Don't know if has been compared to the new Rosetta's though.

Lynx also has the new Aurora's coming out, which they advertise as "Mastering Quality" converters. If they truly are THAT good, I plan on picking up the Aurora 16. Sixteen channels of "Mastering Quality" conversion for something like $3500 is a damn good deal.

As in every other thing in life, you will never know untill you have tried it.

I have the AES16 card witch is a good AES/EBU audio routing card but my DA converter needed a very high quality AES/EBU signal and with the standart Lynx cable and the standart parts on the PCI card my converter revealed some low quality transfering parts and low quality cable. So I modified the AES16 card to sound better and much more contrasted through my converter, I would say that i got an improvement of over 50%.

So lynx is good, but to call it mastering quality...? Well maybe it is when considering all the compromises that is legalized in mastering. So what I'm saying is that Lynx isn't High End.

Best Regards

You did what? This makes no sense whatsoever!! I use Lynx converters, superb...

Care to explain your mod a bit more just out of curiousity? Thanx :D

Ammitsboel Tue, 12/07/2004 - 02:01

timster wrote: [quote=Ammitsboel][quote=Johnjm22]You did what? This makes no sense whatsoever!! I use Lynx converters, superb...

Care to explain your mod a bit more just out of curiousity? Thanx :D

If your converter doesn't care much about the quality of the AES/EBU(some don't) then you will get absolutely nothing out of doing this.
As i wrote earlier i modified the AES/EBU sending circuit by removing the parts on the PCI board and replacing them with the best I could find, and I also did a small change in the circuit.
You will have to be good at soldering to do this as it involves removing small smd components.

Best Regards,

timster Tue, 12/07/2004 - 04:41

Ammitsboel wrote: [quote=timster][quote=Ammitsboel][quote=Johnjm22]You did what? This makes no sense whatsoever!! I use Lynx converters, superb...

Care to explain your mod a bit more just out of curiousity? Thanx :D

If your converter doesn't care much about the quality of the AES/EBU(some don't) then you will get absolutely nothing out of doing this.
As i wrote earlier i modified the AES/EBU sending circuit by removing the parts on the PCI board and replacing them with the best I could find, and I also did a small change in the circuit.
You will have to be good at soldering to do this as it involves removing small smd components.

Best Regards,

Cool. So you are saying you didnt like the AES/EBUto start with and were able to improve it? Are the mods available on line or is it something you figured out yourself?

Ammitsboel Tue, 12/07/2004 - 06:30

timster wrote:
Cool. So you are saying you didnt like the AES/EBUto start with and were able to improve it? Are the mods available on line or is it something you figured out yourself?

Yes i didn't like them to begin with.
But still better than RME's AES/EBU interfaces.

There is nothing about the mod online... with High End you are on your own.
A confirmation of this is that Lynx didn't even care that I modified their PCI card = they don't care about High End.
It take a lot more than a test bench and a few designers to make High End.

As a firm that makes sound equipment you have to be open about these things or you are going to dig your own grave and contribute to the wonders of the mediocre lane.

Write to my email if you want to discus if the mod would be an improvement for you.

Best Regards,

anonymous Thu, 12/30/2004 - 08:51

So I think the prefered digital interface here is AES/EBU for getting signals in and out of the DAW and to/from the DAC/ADC. Any recomendations for a PCI card with AES/EBU? I know Ammitsboel doesnt like the RME, but that is the only one I know of. Is s/pdif a viable option for digital transfer to and from the DAW to the DAC/ADC?

x