Skip to main content

If I'm working on editing audio or working on midi in Reason or Logic (using the midi controller keyboard to play with the vsts), do I need to get a pci card for powerbook or is the card which comes with the Powerbook good enough? what is the latency like?

Comments

anonymous Tue, 11/01/2005 - 04:25

The internal sound is ok, it's limited to a stereo mini-jack and 16-bit audio. I've only used the internal with a USB keyboard, and headphones.

Much better quality with an external interface that actually has the capability to hook-up a mike or guitar.

yupp!!! and if a seperate interface then firewire, stay away from usb for audio... both HDs and interface FIREWIRE only.

gdoubleyou Tue, 11/01/2005 - 14:59

USB uses more CPU cycles to manage itself. I have never tested a USB2 device that has come close to it's theoretical max bandwidth.
It approaches that speed in bursts, firewire appears to have a higher sustained bandwith.

True firewire devices don't require a computer, like the devices that you connect directly to DV camcorders, their brains are in firmware. Firewire home theater solutions identify and send the proper signals to surround systems.

I work in a lab that tests a lot of devices, for use in airborne data systems. Believe me there is a lot of hype out there.

Most current firewire drives only use a small part of the spec, but we should soon see some standalone audio devices in the years to come.

8)

anonymous Wed, 11/02/2005 - 13:28

gdoubleyou wrote:

USB uses more CPU cycles to manage itself. I have never tested a USB2 device that has come close to it's theoretical max bandwidth.
It approaches that speed in bursts, firewire appears to have a higher sustained bandwith.

same experience here, i had specially trouble (and some of my friends / collegs) with using USB in a chain, firewire, no problem specially for laptops on one bus HD, Interface, external burner, no probs at all... i think it's because usb transfers data "info after info" and firewire "info next to info" like on a multi lane highway, so you can get easy a sort of "data traffic jam" with USB.

the actual transfer speed is also much higher, the specs on paper i believe is 400mbs for firefire and 480 for usb 2.0 that's rubish and equals the specs of behringer gear, and we all know what it is like in reality!

appart that you don't get any serious quality interface as an usb version, only the cheap stuff.

x