Skip to main content

Hi,
I just recorded a great Acoustic Guitar track that has string squeaks that I want to try and calm down. Maybe thru a deEsser or EQ..Any helpful suggestions rather than re recording?
Thanks,

Comments

took-the-red-pill Tue, 12/20/2005 - 23:06

Being a guitar player of, at best, dubious talent, I am becoming a bit of a master at crossfading, editing and fixing my botched guitar tracks. :oops:

I have found that since one doesn't want to affect the EQ on the rest of the track, the best tack for me has been to locate the offending parts and automate the EQ to take a huge dip in the right frequency(s) at the right time.

I know that that's essentially what a de-esser does, but you have more control if you isolate the frequency and do it as an automation. Sometimes the bulk of a squeak happens at a higher or lower frequency than other times, and it can help to look at each one individually instead of just setting a de-esser and walking away.

By the way, I have found that with me, the squeak often happens at a much lower frequency than I would have thought, often centred around 2500Hz or so.

If it's important, you might be best to give it another shot.

(The preceding opinion is only that of the poster, and does not necessarily represent the opinions of anyone else, living or dead... )

soapfloats Thu, 01/08/2009 - 23:38

Kudos red-pill !

I was actually trying to deal with this specific problem earlier tonight.

I tried a couple of de-essers and none of them... get this, went low enough to hit the right frequency! (around 2kHz) :shock:

To Greg: Can you offer up any that have those presets? Do they go down in the 1.5-2.5 kHz range? Thanks if you can point me in the right direction.

All said, I've learned my lesson and will take preventative measures in the future - though it never hurts to have a workable fix in the bag.

anonymous Fri, 01/09/2009 - 04:47

Instead of a de-esser you might try a compressor with a side chain. That way you can use what ever EQ you want for the squeak noise. If you use Pro Tools the one built in has this function. Here are a couple of free ones that should do the trick:

ReaComp from Cockos (makers of Reaper)
Vanilla Compressor from ChunkWare

pr0gr4m Fri, 01/09/2009 - 12:23

Let the guitarist listen back to the track. Tell him you think there may be too much squeakiness. If he's happy with it, then you're ok. If he isn't, then he may want to do another take...or you should ask him to do another take. A lot of the squeakyness is due to technique (or lack thereof) and if the artist feels that it's too much, he should be able to alter his playing a bit to minimize the squeakiness.

jm2 Thu, 01/15/2009 - 13:06

Of course flat wound strings will quell squeak completely. Admittedly, some players do not like flatwounds, claiming they have not the same edge or brightness as roundwound. This is partially true, but for recording, a very fresh set would probably be as lively as a settled in set of round wound.

Not all flatwounds are the same. In fact, the brighter sounding flatwounds are actually round wound then ground semi-flat. True flatwounds, as in winding a ribbon onto a core, are indeed quite dull to the uninitiated, but ground semi-flats are acceptably bright. D'addario Flat tops would be the go to string if one absolutely needed a string with no squeak.

I used roundwound for many years, then switched to flatwound (ground) on acoustic and electric for a decade, and recently switched back to round on acoustic for a bit brighter sound. Still, flatwound might eliminate your sqeaks without manipulating the tracks by some other more invasive means.